Category Archives: Kelly

Fall to my knees

Kelly Jo Feinberg
October 8, 1972 – May 14, 2010

There is something so satisfying about weeding my garden. Unlike most chores or the work I do teaching and writing, where it can be hard to measure success or even know when a thing is finished, when you weed you can see clearly what you’ve accomplished, a cleared space. There is a distinct before and after.

Working in my garden never fails to make me think about Kelly. Sixteen years ago, (HOW has it already been 16 years, and yet also so much has happened since then), when the message arrived that Kelly was being sent home with hospice care, that there was nothing else they could do for her, that the moment we wished and prayed wouldn’t ever arrive was now there, we were going to lose her, her physical body was going to die and it would happen soon, all I could think to do is fall to my knees in my garden and pull weeds.

At that time, I still held a sense of disbelief around death. Yes, my grandparents had already died and of course someday far in the future my parents would follow, but death closer than that felt unfair, unnatural, practically impossible. My first dog Obi was diagnosed with a treatable but ultimately incurable cancer the same week as Kelly got her breast cancer diagnosis, but as hard as it was and would be, I knew most if not all of my dogs would all die before I did, but certainly not Kelly. She would be treated and live to be free of cancer. There didn’t seem any other possible option. And yet, six months after Obi died, Kelly would follow.

I’m aware now, 16 years later, having lost two more dogs, my sister-in-law, three of my “other” mothers, two beloved uncles, my dad and now so near to losing my mom altogether, that death isn’t just close, it’s my roommate. And every time, I fall to my knees and weed the garden. With each loss, I plant another peony bush in the center where the massive cottonwood tree used to stand.

As I live with this deepened intimate awareness of death, with the compound grief of so much loss, I am also aware that death doesn’t remove someone completely. Just like the bindweed in my garden that I pull and pull, season after season, the roots of love are deep and it continues to linger, to hold on. In this way, we never really entirely lose those we love. They are with us still, years later. We can no longer hear their voice or their laugh, we cannot hug them or hold their hand, and yet they are undeniably there, solid and present.

After Kelly died, some of us started to see ladybugs. Ladybugs are thought to be a positive omen representing good luck, prosperity, love, and protection. They are a reminder that she is still with us, that everything is okay, even when it isn’t. This year in my garden, maybe something to do with the warmer than usual winter, there are so many ladybugs, more than I’ve ever seen before. I was out just this morning, on my knees in my garden pulling weeds, and they were everywhere.

More things I’ve written about Kelly:

  • Kelly Jo, October 8, 2011: “It’s cloudy, windy, gray, with a little bit of rain here today. That seems right. Today is Kelly’s birthday.”
  • Dance Party, October 8, 2011: “A while back, I wrote an essay and made a dance party mix tape in Kelly’s honor and mailed it to some friends.”
  • The world is never the same after she is there, May 14, 2012: “‘A girl who knows who she is shows up with so much light, confidence and love for everyone and everything around her that the room, the world is never the same after she is there.’ This quote describes my friend Kelly perfectly–so much light, confidence and love for everyone and everything around her—her life, her presence on this earth meant the world would never be the same, and two years ago today, the world was forever changed in another way when she passed.”
  • Don’t Give Up, May 14, 2014: “This was the view this morning from my front porch, just as Eric and I were leaving to walk the dogs. It makes sense that the sky was extra beautiful this morning. Four years ago on May 14th, Kelly died, and while that remains one of the worst things, she was one of the best.”
  • Day of Rest: Remembering Kelly, May 15, 2016: “About a week ago, I went out to check how many blooms my peonies would have this year. I have three of them — one for Obi, one for Kelly, and one for Heather and now Dexter, planted at the edge of the spot where our Cottonwood tree used to be, a tiny memorial to so much loss. As I counted the blooms, I noticed one had a friend, a ladybug. It always feels like a nudge from Kelly, and to see one on my peonies is a double whammy.”
  • Three Truths and One Wish, May 14, 2019: “Grief is something you never get over, you just get used to it. Nine years ago today, Kelly died.”
  • On the Origins of Things, October 8, 2019: “Today would have been my friend Kelly’s birthday. Would have been, because nine years ago, at only 37 years old, she died.”

Don’t Give Up

This was the view this morning from my front porch, just as Eric and I were leaving to walk the dogs. It makes sense that the sky was extra beautiful this morning. Four years ago on May 14th, Kelly died, and while that remains one of the worst things, she was one of the best.

Eric said to me once, after she was gone, “I don’t understand why you are so upset about it, it’s not like you were best friends.” He’s right. Since Kelly had moved to Kentucky with her husband Matt, I hadn’t even heard her voice. We kept in touch through email, regular mail, her blog, and Facebook. Even that contact was spotty, until she was diagnosed with cancer. Things like that — accidents, illness, even death — have a way of shaking you up, waking you up. You suddenly realize how much people mean to you and you start to act like it.

In some ways, I realized how much I adored Kelly too late. There wasn’t much time to act like it, for her to know it (although, I made sure she did). I trusted in the hope she had that she’d get better (how could she not?!), and planned to go visit her then, to celebrate. I never got the chance to see her again, would travel to her memorial service instead. It was better than I’d done for Heather, but still not enough.

And yet, that’s one good thing that came from losing Kelly, (and Obi, and then Dexter) —  I set the intention to heal myself, to be myself, and in that way to start to help make the world better. I vowed to keep my heart open, no matter how bad things got, no matter how hard it might be. I started this blog, I took my work and what I had to offer seriously, I started to love myself, to ease suffering, to see my life as practice and an offering. What I wanted most was to be clear that their lives mattered, that they’d made a difference, and the only way I knew how to do that was through my own experience, by showing up with an open heart.

Kelly was kind, funny, and smart, devoted to making the world a better place. Her last words on this earth were said to her mom — “I’m happy.” That’s so exactly and essentially Kelly. She never gave up loving every minute of her life.

That’s the thing I carry with me, both from her life and her loss: don’t give up. That might sound like a small thing, but it has the power to save us. Me, you, all of us, all of it. Don’t give up. And even when we lose each other in this way, when our love is unbound by form, the love remains. It’s confusing and hard because we no longer have the physical form to attach our attention and affection too, but that connection is never broken. It’s okay. Cheer up. You’re perfect.

Don’t give up.